Are you in the market for a new grill pan? Look no further! We’ve done the research and testing to bring you the ultimate guide to the best grill pans of 2024. Whether you’re a grill master or just starting out, we have the perfect pan for you. So, let’s dive in and find your new cooking companion!
Other Grill Pans We Explored
We understand that everyone has different needs when it comes to their grill pans. That’s why we also tested and reviewed a few other options to give you a comprehensive overview. Among the alternatives, we found the Lodge Chef Collection Seasoned Reversible Grill/Griddle. This versatile $50 pan is perfect for those with long, oval-shaped burners. It offers ample space to cook a variety of foods and produces beautiful char marks. However, if you have a standard stovetop with round burners, we recommend going for a different grill pan.
Another option we explored is the OXO Non-Stick 11-Inch Grill Pan. Made from hard-anodized aluminum with a nonstick coating, this lightweight $50 pan is perfect for everyday use. Its handle stays cool while cooking, and it creates grill marks, although it’s not ideal for fatty meats. So, keep these alternatives in mind as you make your decision.
Things to Consider When Choosing a Grill Pan
Material
When it comes to grill pans, nothing beats cast iron. The superior heat retention and even distribution make it the go-to material for perfect grilling. However, if you want a low-maintenance option, consider an enamel-coated model like the Le Creuset Signature Cast Iron Grill Pan or Staub Enameled Cast Iron Grill Pan. These pans offer the best of both worlds: easy cleaning and the heat retention of cast iron.
Size and Shape
Choosing the right size and shape for your grill pan is essential. In our testing, we found that square options generally fit more food. Aim for a 10 to 12-inch pan that offers enough surface area for grilling without overcrowding. Additionally, ensure that the pan fits fully on your stove’s burner to achieve even heat distribution.
Don’t forget to consider the height of the pan’s walls. Higher walls make flipping large pieces of meat easier and reduce grease splatter. So, keep these factors in mind while making your selection.
Handles
Handling a cast iron grill pan can be a challenge due to its weight. Look for pans with well-designed handles that make it easier to move on and off the burner. Some models, like the Lodge Grill Pan, have a long pan handle and a smaller loop handle on the front, giving you multiple ways to pick it up. Alternatively, pans with two loop-style handles, such as the Victoria Cast Iron Grill Pan, offer a lighter weight and easier storage.
Our Testing Process
To find the best grill pans of 2024, we rigorously tested 20 different models over a total of 28 hours. We cooked a variety of dishes, including grilled cheese, roasted zucchini, pork chops, hamburgers, and even pancakes on griddle-compatible pans. Throughout the testing, we evaluated factors such as ergonomics, heat distribution, retention, performance, and ease of cleaning to determine each pan’s strengths and weaknesses.
After completing the testing phase, we scored each product based on design, ease of use, performance, and ease of cleaning. The Lodge Cast Iron Square Grill Pan emerged as the top performer, earning a perfect 5 out of 5. It was closely followed by the Le Creuset Signature Cast Iron Grill Pan, which also delivered exceptional results.
Why Trust Us?
At PEOPLE, we take our testing seriously. Camryn Rabideau, our freelance writer and product tester specializing in home products, has firsthand experience testing various grill pans, including the popular Cuisinart Enameled Square Grill Pan. Leveraging insights from our PEOPLE Tested team and expert interviews with food blogger Yaz Pernell and chef David Figueroa, we’re here to guide you toward the best grill pan for your kitchen.
What Is PEOPLE Tested?
The PEOPLE Tested seal of approval ensures that you find the very best products for your life. We use a unique methodology to test products across three labs and engage our network of home testers to evaluate their effectiveness, durability, ease of use, and more. Based on our results, we rate and recommend products so that you can make informed decisions.
But it doesn’t stop there. We regularly re-review categories to ensure that our recommendations remain up to date. And remember, our recommendations can never be bought. Products must earn our seal of approval fair and square.
In a nutshell, PEOPLE Tested provides trustworthy recommendations every day, with every purchase.
Now that you’re armed with all the information you need, it’s time to choose your perfect grill pan. Happy grilling!