The Ultimate Guide to Creating Perfect Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Grilled cheese sandwiches are the epitome of comfort food. They transport us back to cherished childhood memories of cozy days at home, dipping a crispy sandwich into a warm bowl of tomato soup. These sandwiches hold a special place in our hearts, bringing comfort and satisfaction with every gooey, melty bite. Whether you’re reminiscing about snow days or looking for a delightful snack, the key to a sensational grilled cheese lies in the cheese itself. While any semi-hard cheese can work, some cheeses excel at achieving that signature cheese pull we all crave. Join me as I share the 12 best cheeses for creating superior grilled cheese sandwiches!

Tips for Creating the Perfect Grilled Cheese

Before we dive into the cheese selection, let’s first uncover some secrets to crafting the perfect grilled cheese sandwich. These tips will help you achieve an evenly golden, crispy crust with a delightful melty interior.

  • Mayonnaise & butter: Spread a thin layer of mayonnaise on the outside of each slice of bread before grilling. This unusual technique adds a delicious crispness to the sandwich.
  • Low heat: Cook the sandwich at a low heat to ensure that the cheese melts at the same rate as the exterior browns. This ensures a perfect balance of texture and flavor.
  • Shredded cheese: Opt for shredded cheese or thin slices to ensure quick melting. Shredding a block of cheese yourself is recommended to avoid any additives that hinder melting.
  • The bread: Use white bread for a classic grilled cheese with a light and fluffy interior or opt for a crusty loaf like sourdough for a crunchier exterior. Experiment with different bread types to find your favorite combination.
  • The pan: To achieve the perfect toast on your bread while melting the cheese, use a pan that evenly conducts heat, such as a cast iron skillet or non-stick sauté pan.
See also  Easy Recipe: Mastering the Art of Reduction Sauce

Now that we have the basics covered, let’s explore the 12 best cheeses to take your grilled cheese sandwich to the next level.

American Cheese

American cheese may be processed, but it’s a classic choice for a reason. Its superior melting ability and gooey texture make it ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches. Whether you prefer Kraft or Velveeta, these mild slices are easy to layer and add a delightful flavor to your sandwich. Serve them on their own or pair them with a bowl of tomato soup or a side of ketchup for a nostalgic experience. For a more flavorful twist, combine American cheese with Cheddar or Monterey Jack.

Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar cheese is a crowd-pleaser, and it melts beautifully in grilled cheese sandwiches. Opt for mild or medium Cheddar, as sharp Cheddar can become oily and waxy when melted. Experiment with different fillings like chopped pimento peppers, slices of tomato, strips of crispy bacon, or even mac and cheese for an indulgent treat. The rich, buttery flavor of Cheddar pairs well with pickles, adding a tangy contrast to your sandwich.


Consider using double cream Brie for your grilled cheese sandwich. Its mild flavor and gooey consistency make every bite a delight. Pair it with cured meats like prosciutto or shaved ham for a savory twist, or add some fig jam or chopped blackberries for a unique sweet and savory combination.

Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack is a versatile semi-hard cheese that melts well, making it perfect for grilled cheese sandwiches. Its mild, buttery flavor creates a delightful base for a variety of fillings. Try buffalo chicken, pulled pork, or chopped kimchi for a more complex sandwich, and don’t forget to add a few pickled jalapeños for a hint of spice.

See also  Choose between Steaks or Chops: A Delectable Dilemma

Pepper Jack Cheese

If you’re looking for a little kick in your grilled cheese, Pepper Jack cheese is the way to go. It combines the creamy texture and buttery taste of Monterey Jack with the added heat of red pepper. Use it with grilled peppers and onions or leftover chicken tinga for a flavorful and satisfying experience.


Gouda, a semi-hard cow’s milk cheese from the Netherlands, offers a mild, caramel-like flavor. While aged Gouda doesn’t melt as well, regular Gouda is perfect for grilled cheese. Pair it with roasted red peppers for an extra burst of flavor.


Havarti is a semi-soft Danish cow’s milk cheese that melts well and has a subtle flavor. Shred it and add sautéed and chopped broccoli rabe or sautéed spinach and artichoke hearts for a delicious twist. For something truly unique, try a lobster and avocado grilled cheese recipe with Havarti.


Fontina, a mild cow’s milk cheese from Italy, melts beautifully, creating that desired gooey, stringy cheese pull. Use it in recipes like truffle grilled cheese with sautéed mushrooms, truffle oil, and arugula. Add a drizzle of honey or hot honey for a touch of sweetness.


Gruyère, a hard cheese from Switzerland, pairs its distinct nutty, warm, and sweet flavor with perfect melting capabilities. It’s an ideal addition to a grilled cheese sandwich, especially when combined with shaved ham or fresh chopped herbs and caramelized onions.


Provolone, a smooth and creamy semi-firm Italian cheese, melts beautifully, creating a melty, stringy sandwich. Pair it with slices of tomato, a spoonful of homemade pesto, or chopped oregano and basil for a gourmet garlic bread-inspired sandwich.

See also  Indulge in the Exquisite Flavor of Garlic Butter Steak and Potatoes


Part-skim mozzarella is an excellent choice for grilled cheese sandwiches due to its low-moisture and dry texture. This type of mozzarella melts better than fresh mozzarella, which tends to become runny. Pair it with tomato slices, fresh basil, and balsamic glaze for a delicious Caprese grilled cheese.

Blue Cheese

While not the most traditional choice, blue cheese melts surprisingly well and adds a distinctive sharp, tangy, and salty flavor. Combine it with another mild cheese like Fontina or mild white Cheddar, and experiment with fillings like sautéed mushrooms, caramelized onions, thinly sliced steak, or even slices of fruit like apples or pears. Blue cheese also pairs wonderfully with salty bacon and sweet fig jam.

Explore the World of Grilled Cheese

Now that you have discovered the 12 best cheeses for grilled cheese sandwiches, it’s time to embark on a delicious journey. Gather your favorite cheese, bread, and fillings, and start experimenting. Whether you’re seeking a classic comfort food experience or a gourmet twist, there’s a grilled cheese combination waiting for you. Enjoy the melty, gooey deliciousness that comes with each bite, and remember, the possibilities are endless with the right cheese. So go ahead and indulge in the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich experience!

Hook’d Up Bar and Grill