Eco-Friendly Skillets: Are They Worth the Hype?

In recent years, it seems like every product has undergone an environmentally friendly makeover, from shopping bags to SUVs. Non-stick skillets are no exception. Enter eco-friendly non-stick pans, promising longer-lasting coatings that resist scratches and can handle higher temperatures than traditional non-stick options.

Traditional non-stick coatings often contain two controversial chemicals: PFOA and PTFE. While PFOA is no longer present in the pans upon purchase, it is used in the manufacturing process and can end up in the environment, wildlife, drinking water, food, and even human blood samples. PTFE, on the other hand, is the very coating responsible for making the non-stick surface slippery.

Although consuming small amounts of the PTFE coating is not dangerous, heating the pan above 660 degrees Fahrenheit can release fumes that cause flu-like symptoms in humans. This raises concerns about the safety of traditional non-stick pans.

To address these concerns, eco-friendly skillets have emerged, using alternative coatings to eliminate the need for PFOA while still utilizing PTFE. These new coatings include ceramics, silicone polymers, and PTFE without PFOA.

To evaluate the claims of these eco-friendly skillets, we tested eight different brands, ranging from $32 to nearly $140. In each skillet, we cooked a variety of dishes that non-stick pans excel at: scrambled eggs, fish fillets, steak, and stir-fries. We also used metal utensils and assessed the durability of the coatings as we cooked and washed the pans repeatedly. Additionally, we considered the pan’s design, balance, weight, and shape since these factors contribute to a great cooking experience, regardless of the eco-friendliness.

See also  How to Make a Perfect Roast Beef: 5 Expert Tips

Unfortunately, the results were not entirely promising. None of the eco-friendly skillets we tested were flawless. Eggs burned, fish stuck, and steak charred on the outside while remaining raw inside. Some skillets stained easily, heated inconsistently, or developed fond, indicating food sticking. Scratch resistance was also tested by making frittatas and slicing them directly in the pans with knives, as well as using metal spatulas to serve them. Despite claims of superior non-stick capabilities, all the skillets showed marks and scratches.

It turns out that the ceramic coatings were too brittle and lacked durability, while the silicone polymers started to deteriorate after a few weeks of use. The only skillets that performed reasonably well were those using PTFE in their coating without the addition of PFOA during manufacturing.

In conclusion, while a truly eco-friendly non-stick skillet is an admirable goal, none of the pans we tested fully met the mark. We’ll have to wait for the next generation of green pans. In the meantime, sticking with traditional non-stick skillets or a well-seasoned cast iron pan, which is the original non-stick option, seems like the safer and more reliable choice.

Eco-Friendly Skillets: Are They Worth the Hype?
Eco-Friendly Skillets: Are They Worth the Hype?

Table of Contents


  1. Are eco-friendly skillets safe to use?

    • Eco-friendly skillets aim to eliminate the use of PFOA, a potentially harmful chemical, while still incorporating PTFE. However, the effectiveness and safety of these skillets vary. It is important to research and choose reputable brands with reliable reviews and certifications.
  2. What are the alternatives to eco-friendly skillets?

    • If you prefer non-stick cookware but have concerns about eco-friendly options, you can opt for traditional non-stick skillets or use a well-seasoned cast iron pan, which has been a trusted non-stick choice for generations.
  3. How can I ensure the longevity of my non-stick cookware?

    • To prolong the life of your non-stick cookware, avoid using metal utensils that can scratch the coating. Instead, opt for silicone, nylon, or wooden utensils. Additionally, handwashing with mild detergent is recommended, as dishwashers can be harsh on the non-stick surface.
See also  Preparing an Unforgettable Thanksgiving Feast with Hook'd Up Bar and Grill


Although eco-friendly skillets aim to address environmental concerns associated with traditional non-stick pans, our tests revealed that current options still have room for improvement. While we look forward to the next generation of green pans, for now, it may be best to rely on trusted traditional non-stick skillets or the tried-and-true cast iron pan for our cooking needs. For more information on Hook’d Up Bar and Grill, visit Hook’d Up Bar and Grill.

Leave a Comment